Facebook is Haram ? - Facebook Fatwa Haram who want issued by scholars in East Java, the challenges get harder from Facebook users. According to the scholars that they must provide proof that immediately before the issue decision unlawful Facebook.
"Fatwa is really not realistic. Ulama must show proof that the right because Facebook also provides a positive impact, why," Chandra muttering hero one of Facebook activists, such as that quoted from Okezone.com, Friday (21/05)
Also added, such as social networking site Facebook that would have very strict rules. One example, if Facebook users display images from a chest to the top, then the manager will immediately close it. So be spelled out, Facebook already has its own filter.
In addition, according to men aged 28 years, if the scholars would like to block social networking, Facebook should not only just. Many other social networking sites such as Friendster or Myspace. And if you really like that, the same scholars prohibit the use of the Internet into Indonesia.
"Activities in the virtual world requires the interaction between men and women. And that depends on the individual in private mengontrolnya. Fact be spelled out, which oversees the activities of the virtual world, only himself and the angels," specifically.
Some other users of Facebook is intensely manage their own opinions of each, but essentially all of which give one vote unanimously, the regret attitude if Facebook MUI akan difatwakan unlawful.
"I agree that the main Facebook spelled forbidden. The problem is that I see more good than keburukannya," said Cempaka opinions when asked by Okezone. 21 freshman this year also added, Facebook is in helping keep in touch and find back old friends.
This senada expressed by other Facebook users, Adinda, 23 years old, a journalist one of the online media keberatannya issue fatwa haram Facebook.
"It is not important to the fatwa haram Facebook, a relevant aja. Moreover I have never find the facts and data that reveal the impact of Facebook misused for sexual activities hidden. Impact of the poor often I hear this, most just make sure pengaksesnya themselves and I think is still reasonable. Depending same time each is, "he said.
Adinda also add, if so akan Facebook difatwakan forbidden, it should also apply to other social networking sites.
"Indeed, at this time the boom phenomenon Facebook, but if the users are prohibited from accessing Facebook, how about the other social networking sites?. If I want forbidden finicky?. If Facebook closed, they can still switch to other social networking sites," he said .
Cempaka correct to say that if Facebook difatwakan akan forbidden, it is likely he will switch to using other social networking sites.
"If indeed correct forbidden, I still have some accounts in the social networking sites like MySpace and the other,"
Meanwhile, Apriarto, 27 years, said not a problem for him in case Facebook forbidden. He holds this phenomenon is a fraction of the impact of the internet boom around the world.
However Apriarto them with similar phenomena that have occurred previously, because this does not only happen in Indonesia. On the other country also has many religious objections of the negative impact on various social networking sites.
"Facebook is a chance the current flare. But if the new MUI now give attention on the impact of bad internet boom, where it is MUI? Day gini kok new comments?" explicitly.
Tulisan diatas ditranslate secara langsung dari sumber asli yang berbahasa di Indonesia melalui artikel Facebook Haram?
"Fatwa is really not realistic. Ulama must show proof that the right because Facebook also provides a positive impact, why," Chandra muttering hero one of Facebook activists, such as that quoted from Okezone.com, Friday (21/05)
Also added, such as social networking site Facebook that would have very strict rules. One example, if Facebook users display images from a chest to the top, then the manager will immediately close it. So be spelled out, Facebook already has its own filter.
In addition, according to men aged 28 years, if the scholars would like to block social networking, Facebook should not only just. Many other social networking sites such as Friendster or Myspace. And if you really like that, the same scholars prohibit the use of the Internet into Indonesia.
"Activities in the virtual world requires the interaction between men and women. And that depends on the individual in private mengontrolnya. Fact be spelled out, which oversees the activities of the virtual world, only himself and the angels," specifically.
Some other users of Facebook is intensely manage their own opinions of each, but essentially all of which give one vote unanimously, the regret attitude if Facebook MUI akan difatwakan unlawful.
"I agree that the main Facebook spelled forbidden. The problem is that I see more good than keburukannya," said Cempaka opinions when asked by Okezone. 21 freshman this year also added, Facebook is in helping keep in touch and find back old friends.
This senada expressed by other Facebook users, Adinda, 23 years old, a journalist one of the online media keberatannya issue fatwa haram Facebook.
"It is not important to the fatwa haram Facebook, a relevant aja. Moreover I have never find the facts and data that reveal the impact of Facebook misused for sexual activities hidden. Impact of the poor often I hear this, most just make sure pengaksesnya themselves and I think is still reasonable. Depending same time each is, "he said.
Adinda also add, if so akan Facebook difatwakan forbidden, it should also apply to other social networking sites.
"Indeed, at this time the boom phenomenon Facebook, but if the users are prohibited from accessing Facebook, how about the other social networking sites?. If I want forbidden finicky?. If Facebook closed, they can still switch to other social networking sites," he said .
Cempaka correct to say that if Facebook difatwakan akan forbidden, it is likely he will switch to using other social networking sites.
"If indeed correct forbidden, I still have some accounts in the social networking sites like MySpace and the other,"
Meanwhile, Apriarto, 27 years, said not a problem for him in case Facebook forbidden. He holds this phenomenon is a fraction of the impact of the internet boom around the world.
However Apriarto them with similar phenomena that have occurred previously, because this does not only happen in Indonesia. On the other country also has many religious objections of the negative impact on various social networking sites.
"Facebook is a chance the current flare. But if the new MUI now give attention on the impact of bad internet boom, where it is MUI? Day gini kok new comments?" explicitly.
Tulisan diatas ditranslate secara langsung dari sumber asli yang berbahasa di Indonesia melalui artikel Facebook Haram?
1 komentar :
Assalammualaikum,
If you ever taken a course like Usul Fiqh, or anything that is related to the Syariah (Fundamental Laws of Islam – Qura’n and Hadith (sayings and past activities of Rasulullah SAW)).. you will know about the procedures to creating a derivational laws based on the fundamental laws.
Fundamental Laws ->(human derivation)-> Derivational Laws
Determining whether Facebook is Halal or Haraam is a Derivational case. But keep in mind that Allah SWT have said:
“This day I have perfected your religion for you, completed My Favor upon you, and have chosen for you Islam as your religion” (al- Ma`idah: 3)
The Fundamental Laws are perfect, thus the derivational laws depends on the capacity of thinking of human beings.
The scholars of Islam is really important and serves as fences so that Muslims do not step out of the boundaries which Allah SWT has defined.
For those of us who are not scholars, and are not knowlegable enough, please be careful of how you make an analysis and how you derive conclusions based on it.
Last but not least, the Muslim Scholar Association of Indonesian might have a different Fatwa than the Muslim Scholar Association in Russia, Egypt, USA, etc. That is why it’s called a fatwa. An Ijma have a higher authority than Fatwa. An Ijma is a derived law which is undisputed among all Scholars association throughout the world.
As for me, I’m not a scholar, I’m not a knowledgeable person, but I have took some Islam-related short courses. Hope this helps.
Wallahualam (Allah knows best)
Posting Komentar